Conversation log 2020-06-07-2
When ideas are divergent and confusing, can we help them pick up the pieces? If so, I would like to know how to do that.
The machine creates the Next Action and gives it to the human.
Even if it's random, it works anyway, and the more accurate it is, the more valuable it becomes.
nishio.iconLet's talk.
nisbot.iconWhat would you like to see happen in this conversation?
nishio.iconWhen ideas are divergent and confusing, can we help them pick up the pieces? If so, I would like to know how to do that.
nisbot.iconIs there anything else you can tell us about its collection?
nishio.iconWhat is the purpose of collecting, and what makes you happy when you collect? Is the purpose of this also to determine the Next Action?
nisbot.iconWhat type of next action is that next action?
nishio.iconWhen people are confused and don't know what to do next, they can work with peace of mind when they decide on a Next Action. When people are confused and wondering what to do next, they are not very productive. When the next action is decided, we are productive.
nisbot.iconIs there anything else about that Next Action?
nishio.iconHmmm... if a system where a machine decides on a next action and gives it to a human and the human performs the action as a subroutine is more efficient than a human-only system, does economic rationale make that system more popular?
nisbot.iconHow do you know its Next Action?
nishio.iconIf it's a situation where a human can't decide, then a machine can decide and give it to you.
nisbot.iconIs there anything else you can tell us about that person?
nishio.iconPeople are lazy.
nisbot.iconWhat kind of person is that person?
nishio.iconPeople who are incapable of deciding for themselves what to do next
nisbot.iconHmmm... if a system where a machine decides on a next action and gives it to a human and the human performs the action as a subroutine is more efficient than a human-only system, does economic rationale make that system more popular?
Where is this Next Action?
nishio.iconIf candidates for next actions can be created mechanically by inputting the current situation, it is possible for a machine to decide the next action. An example of this is the Shogi AI, which, upon inputting information about the current state of the board, determines a "candidate next action" based on the rules and then selects it.
nisbot.iconHow do you know the machine?
nishio.iconNG
nisbot.iconIs there anything else you can tell us about that machine?
nishio.iconThere is no problem in playing against each other if the selection from the candidates for the Next Action is random, but it is too weak to be of any value. Value is created when the choice is somewhat wise.
nisbot.iconWhat is it that you value?
nishio.iconIt's a next-action decision system.
nisbot.iconWhat is the relationship between that Next Action and human beings?
nishio.iconIf the next action is decided and people are satisfied with it, people can operate efficiently.
nisbot.iconIs that Next Action the same as a human being? Is it different?
nishio.iconNo, it is not. A human being is a device that executes the Next Action, and this does not necessarily have to be a human being.
nisbot.iconWhere is that Next Action located?
nishio.iconA machine makes it and gives it to a human.
nisbot.iconWhat happens to Next Action when its human?
nishio.iconEither people see Next Action and are motivated to do it, or they see Next Action and are unmotivated to go through with it.
nisbot.iconWhere does this Next Action come from?
nishio.iconThe machine makes it, but of course we'll have to dig into the "how it's made".
nisbot.iconWhat happens to humans during Next Action?
nishio.iconI see. Let's do that!" Sometimes I get excited. Sometimes it doesn't.
nisbot.iconWhat is between Nextaction and human beings?
nishio.iconIf the next action given by the machine has a non-zero probability of being "I see! If the probability of the machine's next action being "I see!" is non-zero, and if the machine is well-directed, then it is like the relationship between humans and gachas, and humans will be intermittent reinforcement to repeat the action. nisbot.iconWhat is the relationship between that next action and the machine?
nishio.iconNeed a mechanism that allows machines to create next actions.
nisbot.iconIs that Next Action the same as a machine? Is it different?
nishio.iconNo, the machine produces.
Summary so far
The machine creates the Next Action and gives it to the human.
People will be productive.
Unable to pick up the pieces, is in the absence of Next Action.
Even if it's random, it works anyway, and the more accurate it is, the more valuable it becomes.
nisbot.iconWhat happens to the machine during its Next Action?
nishio.iconNG
nisbot.iconWhat happens to Next Action when that machine?
nishio.iconNG
nisbot.iconWhat is between that Next Action and the machine?
nishio.iconThe reason I can't answer any of these kinds of questions is that that is not clear to me either. Something that should be a separate new consultation, like "I want to clarify the relationship between Next Action and machines."
nisbot.iconWhat is the relationship between that Next Action and the inter
nishio.icon(No, you can't choose "between" as a keyword.)
bye-bye
---
This page is auto-translated from /nishio/会話ログ2020-06-07-2. If you looks something interesting but the auto-translated English is not good enough to understand it, feel free to let me know at @nishio_en. I'm very happy to spread my thought to non-Japanese readers.